The feed

Why grounded?

Replies trade half-remembered versions of one story, then drift into job speculation.

Grounded

A post says Bear Bryant's tale of leaving Kentucky over a cigarette lighter likely never happened. Replies argue over the gift and why he left.

Sides

• Told as joke: Bryant told the lighter line as a banquet joke with Rupp present, and it was never the real reason.
• Real slight: Rupp got a new Cadillac while Bryant got only a watch or a lighter, and the gap stung.
• Recruiting limits: Bryant left because Kentucky limited his recruiting and Texas A&M offered him the athletic director job too.

Why grounded?

Replies split on whether the wood points to the ark or needs testing first, and few mention what the drilling team itself has reported.

Grounded

The Noah's Ark Scans team drilling at Durupinar in Turkey says it has not identified any material as ancient wood or dated it. One core hit a hard layer that may be mineralised wood or rock; lab results are expected this winter.

Sides

• Ark evidence: The wood's charred, undecomposed state at the site supports it being genuine remains of the ark.
• Needs testing: No claim about the ark should stand until independent carbon-14 dating and third-party analysis are done.
• Natural wood: Wood at the site could simply be remains of an ancient burnt forest, not evidence of a man-made boat.
• Myth origin: The Noah story echoes older Mesopotamian flood myths, which undercuts treating this site as literal proof of Genesis.

Why grounded?

Replies drift into rival fanbase jabs and old Ballon d'Or grudges.

Grounded

A post says Harry Kane won the Ballon d'Or on padded stats, without a World Cup or Champions League. Replies argue goals versus trophies.

Sides

• Major trophies: In a World Cup year the award should go to winners like Fabian Ruiz or Rodri, not a semifinalist.
• Goal volume: Kane's 73 goals, domestic double and semifinal runs in both tournaments made the strongest individual case.
• Team honours: World Cup and Champions League titles are won by teams, so they should not decide an individual award.

Why grounded?

Replies corrected the post piecemeal and talked past each other instead of comparing notes.

Grounded

A post hails Nancy Astor as the first woman to sit in the Commons. Replies argue over her famous Churchill quotes and her record.

Sides

• Commons pioneer: She took her Commons seat in 1919, after Markievicz declined hers, and held it through decades of ridicule.
• Misattributed quotes: The drunk-and-ugly retort went to Labour MP Bessie Braddock in 1946, and other famous lines have older sources.
• Appeasement record: Her antisemitism and support for appeasing Nazi Germany should weigh against celebrating her as a pioneer.
• Bought access: She got the seat because she was rich and inherited her husband's vacated constituency.

Why grounded?

Replies drifted into owner grievances and jokes instead of answering each other.

Grounded

A post mocks Terry Bradshaw for waiting five weeks to criticize the Cowboys celebrating Dak's touchdown record. Replies split on whether the franchise values milestones over winning.

Sides

• Brand over winning: Dallas has chased publicity and brand value for decades instead of championships, so the criticism lands.
• Normal celebration: Every team celebrates records, and Dak only celebrated after the game was over.
• Earned standing: Four Super Bowl rings give Bradshaw the standing to call out any current quarterback.

Why grounded?

Replies scattered into separate side arguments without engaging one another.

Grounded

A column hails Mourinho's 2-1 Clasico win as classic Mourinho. Replies argue over what counts as a title and whether one win means a revival.

Sides

• Classic Mourinho: Compact defending and counters with 37% possession showed he still outthinks elite opponents.
• Trophy record: Roma's 2022 Conference League and his United trophies count; the 11-year gap is only in league titles.
• One-off: One win against the odds means little until he delivers La Liga or the Champions League.
• Overrated display: Bellingham was only okay in the first half; Guler was the standout midfielder.

Why grounded?

Replies traded insults and league jabs instead of answering each other.

Grounded

A post says Mbappe's 64 goal contributions and three Golden Boots earn him the Ballon d'Or. Replies split on whether team trophies should outweigh scoring.

Sides

• Individual output: World Cup, Champions League and La Liga Golden Boots plus big-game goals outweigh his missing trophies.
• Trophies matter: Team trophies are an official Ballon d'Or criterion; Golden Boots without a trophy fall short.
• Kane first: Kane had more goal contributions, won trophies and knocked Madrid out of the Champions League.

Why grounded?

Replies traded club insults and point-scoring while talking past one another about what counts.

Grounded

A post says Arsenal remain the only side to finish a Premier League season unbeaten. Replies argue over how much that record is worth.

Sides

• Record stands: Going a whole league season unbeaten is unmatched, and a 70% win rate in that campaign is elite.
• Not invincible: That Arsenal side lost 7 games in all competitions that season, so the name oversells it.
• Points matter: They won only 26 games; truly great sides break the 100-point barrier rather than drawing often.
• Living past: The club leaned on that memory for years and played defensive football not to lose.

Why grounded?

The thread splintered into insults and unrelated tangents instead of engaging the original claim.

Grounded

A post says Carragher accused Carrick of deliberately benching Bruno Fernandes to embarrass him. Replies split on whether this was punishment or just football reasoning.

Sides

• Deliberate snub: Carrick deliberately left Bruno on the bench to punish him for calling out the manager midweek.
• Tactical call: At 3-0 down Bruno would not have changed the result, so leaving him out was a football decision.
• Own fault: Bruno brought this on himself through poor captaincy and by publicly criticising the manager midweek.
• Media bias: Carragher's claim is rage bait from a pundit who trashes the club and its players for attention.

Why grounded?

Replies repeat the same historical counterpoints while a side thread drifts into reparations ideology.

Grounded

A post says African kings profited most from the slave trade while British monarchs backed abolition. Replies dispute the crown's own role.

Sides

• Crown implicated: The Royal African Company, chartered by Charles II and run by the future James II, drove the trade.
• British exception: George III and Prince Albert backed abolition, while African kings like Tegbesu and Ghezo profited most.
• Wider blame: Spain, Portugal and Arab traders ran larger or longer-lasting slave trades but escape the same scrutiny as Britain.

Why grounded?

The poster argued with each reply one by one as insults about the fan base piled up.

Grounded

A post defends Miami Hurricanes home attendance by citing tradition, history and a stadium far from campus. Replies argue the crowds are thin anyway.

Sides

• Context matters: Miami is a small private school whose stadium sits 45 minutes from campus, in a city not built around a college.
• Weak crowds: Unless it is an in-state rivalry or Notre Dame, few fans show up, and visiting fans often outnumber them.
• Same everywhere: Most stadiums draw mainly local crowds, since long drives and hotel prices keep out-of-town fans away.

Why grounded?

Replies kept circling the same right-to-know claims with insults aimed at the poster.

Grounded

A post from a developer calls Steam's AI disclosure rule a magnet for review bombs. Replies argue players have a right to know what they buy.

Sides

• Unfair target: Nobody must disclose their engine, assets or plugins, so singling out AI exists only to punish developers.
• Right to know: Many players genuinely want to avoid AI-made games, so a label lets them choose before they buy.
• Inconsistent rule: Steam does not require disclosing AI-generated code, only art, which makes the rule look arbitrary.
• Hiding backfires: Players who dislike AI will find out anyway, and an undisclosed game draws an even worse review bomb.

Why grounded?

Replies traded verdicts on the manager while the stat itself went largely unchallenged.

Grounded

A stat says Chelsea created zero chances in their Premier League derby loss to Tottenham. Replies argue over the number and over who is to blame.

Sides

• Stat is wrong: Chelsea created 6 chances to Tottenham's 9 by a Sky Sports count, and forced several big saves.
• Tactical failure: Xabi Alonso got the tactics wrong, and Tottenham's midfield dominated the game.
• Midfield issue: The Caicedo and Henderson double pivot is not creative, so marking Cole shuts Chelsea down.
• Still building: The manager said from the start the squad is being rebuilt, so one loss should not bring blame.

Why grounded?

Rival fans' mockery drowned out the few replies that engaged the post.

Grounded

A post says the 76ers might be an all-time great team after beating the Knicks and Cavaliers. Replies split on what two early wins show.

Sides

• Real statement: Beating the champion Knicks and the Cavaliers, both at full strength, with a new roster is a strong start.
• Too early: Two regular-season games say little, and the real test comes in the playoffs.
• Shaky wins: The Knicks played badly, and falling 29 behind at home is not what an all-time team does.
• Health doubts: Joel Embiid's health and heavy minutes for him and LeBron James will wear the team down by spring.

Why grounded?

The thread drifted into a front-office blame fight.

Grounded

A post calls the 2024 NFL wide receiver draft class arguably the worst ever. Replies argue over Malik Nabers, injuries and earlier weak classes.

Sides

• Weak class: Malik Nabers is the only one worth much, and the best receiver from that year, Jalen Coker, went undrafted.
• Far from worst: Nabers is a top 10 receiver and Ladd McConkey had 2,000 yards in two seasons, and earlier classes were worse.
• Injury story: Injuries, not talent, have held back players such as Ricky Pearsall, who would rank higher if healthy.

Why grounded?

The thread drifted into side comparisons and insults.

Grounded

A post says Shai Gilgeous-Alexander chose to sit as his record 141-game 20-point streak ended. Replies argue over that choice and the record itself.

Sides

• Unbreakable record: Scoring 20 in 141 straight games will not be matched soon, since the closest recent run was about 71.
• Coach's call: His coach sat him on an off night after he chased points late, so sitting was not his own gesture.
• Not Wilt's streak: He missed games for rest and injury and fell short in playoff games, so it is not what Wilt did.
• Counts as is: Regular-season streaks always count only games played, and he scored 20 every time he suited up.

Why grounded?

Both sides trade screenshots of single games instead of comparing his full career numbers.

Grounded

A post says most of Dak Prescott's stats come from padding in blowout losses. Replies point to his winning record and late comebacks.

Sides

• Garbage time: Much of his production comes once games are out of reach, when defenses ease off and the throws are safe.
• Winning record: A career record well above .500 and repeated 12-5 seasons do not fit a quarterback who only pads stats.
• Clutch drives: His comeback drives and close-game numbers show he delivers when the result is still in doubt.
• Cherry-picked: A handful of blowout screenshots from a long career says little about his overall numbers.

Why grounded?

Replies talked past each other on earnings, debt and valuation.

Grounded

An investor notes SpaceX beat revenue forecasts and guided capex far above consensus, and argues rallies are likely even if the AI trade has peaked. Replies split.

Sides

• Real earnings: Unlike 1999, today's AI leaders have large earnings, so the internet bubble comparison does not fit.
• Debt warning: Off-balance-sheet debt, costly bond issues and unhappy credit markets point to trouble ahead.
• Demand is early: Agentic and physical AI have barely started, so compute demand could grow faster than expected.
• Valuations stretched: SpaceX at around 100 times revenue and trillion-dollar projections look unjustified, and early beats are easy to arrange.

Why grounded?

Replies drifted into accusations and greatest-of-all-time insults instead of the patch.

Grounded

A post says LeBron James' commemorative patch for a record 24th season is a gimmick an all-time great does not need. Replies split.

Sides

• Needless gimmick: All-time greats do not need patches to remind people of their accomplishments.
• Deserved tribute: The league is honouring the longest career in its history, and it is fun for fans.
• Card marketing: Several players wear patches the first week for trading cards; it is the league's idea and about money.
• Longevity isn't greatness: Lasting longest is not the measure; what a player accomplished in his time is.

Why grounded?

Replies swapped win totals without engaging the draft-pick question.

Grounded

A Bucks fan predicts a 26-56 season and argues the year is about developing players and gaining assets. Replies split on that outlook.

Sides

• Rebuild year: Wins are secondary; trading veterans for assets and developing young players should come first, as Oklahoma City did.
• Playoff team: The roster is better than last year and good enough for at least .500 and the play-in.
• Stacked East: The Eastern Conference is deep enough that the Bucks are better than only a couple of teams.
• No reason to lose: The Bucks do not own their upcoming first-round picks, so a losing season brings no reward.

Why grounded?

Replies turned into fan-base rivalry instead of weighing the time slot against the teams.

Grounded

CBS says its 4:25 national window drew 26.4 million viewers and its season is the best ever through Week 6. Replies argue over who deserves the credit.

Sides

• Raiders draw: The Raiders were in both of the top games, so they drive the ratings and deserve a prime-time slot.
• Chiefs draw: The Chiefs are the real draw, as usual, and the Bills should not be grouped with them.
• The time slot: The 4:25 window is effectively a national game, so the slot, not the opponent, brings the audience.
• Bills draw: People tune in to watch Josh Allen and the Bills.

Why grounded?

Replies traded mockery of the record instead of saying what should count.

Grounded

The NBA celebrates Shai Gilgeous-Alexander extending his record run of 20-point games to 141 on opening night. Replies split on what the streak says about him.

Sides

• Historic consistency: Passing Wilt's 126 and averaging over 30 a night for years shows a scorer with no off nights.
• Free throw floor: About ten free throws a game keep him over 20 even on bad shooting nights.
• Playoffs missing: He has had playoff games under 20, so the streak only holds if the playoffs are left out.
• Uncalled violations: Plays that look like travels go uncalled, and the league should address that.

Why grounded?

Replies leaned on slurs and fan jabs instead of the question of what counts as a fair foul.

Grounded

A post calls the idea that Shai Gilgeous-Alexander is unwatchable the worst narrative going. Replies argue over his footwork and his free throws.

Sides

• Elite scorer: His footwork and balance make him one of the best and most watchable scorers in the league.
• Some foul baiting: Some of the foul baiting and flopping has been egregious, though it never made him unwatchable.
• Genuinely fouled: Defenders who cannot stay in front of him really are fouling him, and drawing fouls is part of basketball.
• Changed or same: Some see cleaner buckets this season, while others say it is one game and little has changed.

Why grounded?

Replies traded accusations that the other side's posts came from bots.

Grounded

Amanita Design condemned a fan's AI animations made from Machinarium art. Replies split on whether it is a tribute or copying.

Sides

• Copied art: Feeding hand drawn art into AI copies it without consent, and calling it a love letter hides that.
• Fan tribute: It is fan art made with a different tool, and the studio should thank fans instead of attacking them.
• Shared ideas: Once a work is out in the world, others will build on it, and creators should get used to that.

Why grounded?

Replies cycled through the same objection and personal jabs.

Grounded

Citrini says it used Anthropic's internal research model to design an experimental scorpion antivenom. Replies argue whether a binding result justifies the cost.

Sides

• Binding only: The design binds the toxin but has not been shown to neutralize it, so it is an early result.
• Costly compute: 10,000 H100 hours is a lot for a binding result that a funded postdoc could reach.
• Faster design: Preclinical design is far faster than five years ago and is now 40 to 100 times cheaper than when this began.
• Trials bottleneck: Fast design moves the bottleneck to lab validation and human trials, which still cost millions.

Why grounded?

Replies drifted into insults and speculation unrelated to the question.

Grounded

A post says Howie Roseman should answer for the Eagles' handling of Jalen Hurts' blood clot. Replies split on privacy and legal risk.

Sides

• Owed answers: Roseman oversees the medical staff, and with a player's health at risk he should hold a news conference.
• Legal caution: Any lawyer would tell Roseman to avoid specifics, since his words could be used in litigation.
• Medical privacy: Hurts' medical details are his own, and the team owes the media nothing beyond injury reports.
• Wrong target: The head coach was the wrong person to press on medical decisions, and the questions only feed speculation.

Why grounded?

Replies talked past each other across several separate side threads.

Grounded

A columnist says this World Series pits each league's best team. Replies argue over ratings, small markets and the playoff format.

Sides

• Best vs best: The two best teams by record meet and neither has ever won a title, which makes the series worth watching.
• Ratings slump: Two small market teams will draw the lowest viewership in years, as the 2023 series between Texas and Arizona did.
• Playoff bloat: Expanded playoffs have drained meaning from the regular season, so the best record means less than it should.
• Media narrative: Ratings stories are lazy, since the sport drew big audiences in the 1990s without big market teams.

Why grounded?

Replies piled up personal anecdotes without engaging the post's challenge.

Grounded

A game developer says no AI supporter could name one way AI helps make games. Replies argue over automation, prototyping and game feel.

Sides

• Empty hype: Asked for one concrete way AI helps make games, its supporters give none, which makes the hype bizarre.
• Tedium relief: AI handles debugging, testing, porting and tool building, freeing developers to focus on design and fun.
• Faster prototyping: Building rough versions in days lets developers test more ideas and drop the bad ones sooner.
• Feel by hand: Tuning how a game feels to play still takes slow manual work that AI cannot skip.

Why grounded?

Insults between fans kept derailing the back and forth.

Grounded

A post mocks Jayden Daniels for throwing the ball away on fourth down. Replies argue whether it was a blunder or smart.

Sides

• Poor awareness: Throwing it away on fourth down, a week after forgetting he had no timeouts, shows poor situational awareness.
• Ball security: With a flag on the offense the play was coming back, so throwing it away avoided a costly interception.
• Take a shot: On fourth down you throw to the end zone and give a receiver a chance, since a sack costs nothing extra.
• Open receiver: A receiver was wide open over the middle, so the throw was there to be made.